Showing posts with label low magic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label low magic. Show all posts

Monday, October 5, 2026

Bright-Dark 3d6 Role-Playing Game - Optional Rules

Optional Rules
There are the rules and procedures that people like and use frequently, and then there are the rules and procedures people tend to overlook or neglect. To ease your conscience, I have put those rules in the Optional Rules section. Everything here is indented to be useful and compatible with the tone and playstyle of Bright-Dark.

POINT CRAWL
Imagine arranging the world into a flow chart or a diagram. Locations are points, and the routes between them are lines. Some points are key destinations. Some points are intermittent points representing an obstacle, minor location, rest stop, or a decision point. Pick a line and follow it to the next point. Every time you move from one point to another point is counted as one turn. That's a point crawl. It's simple because it's abstract. The choices presented typically represent the important paths in the world with the unimportant spaces between them being omitted. There's no wandering in circles, finding nothing or getting lost. The GM describes your location, and the players choose a path.

Point Crawls are a middle point between abstraction and simulation. They simplify a complex location; allowing structure and organization without unnecessary precision. Players movement can easily be tracked. The points are treated like a stage for a scene where meaningful information is emphasized rather than a literal location that must be treated realistically. This is why they suit Bright-Dark.

When to Use Point-Crawl, When Not to
You may use point crawls when exploration, discovery and or consequences are emphasized, and when time is a stake. Otherwise, in towns for instance, it's perfectly good to just keep the points as a list, reveal these to the players, and ask where they go.

Turn: When you move from one point to another point, that is one turn. A turn costs player characters in-world time, and the amount depends on the scale of the location. Note that we don't typically linger on the lines. Lines usually represent the stuff in between scenes.

Scale
The scale of the point crawl map depends on the location that the point crawl represents. There are three scales. Dungeon scale is small scale (typically, but hypothetically there can be mega dungeons). Settlement scale is medium scale. Wilderness scale is large scale and can describe a county, kingdom, continent, or even the world.

Dungeon: If the map describes a dungeon, then points are rooms and the paths represent connecting hallways. Moving to a new point and any careful activity in a dungeon (searching, picking locks) is typically a turn and is tracked in 10-minute chunks. Short, simple halls can be traversed in a negligible amount of time, but some halls can be as complex or dangerous as dungeon rooms.

Settlement: If the map describes a village, town, or city, the points are shops, landmarks, major establishments, places of importance, and the lines represent streets. Travel time may be 10-minute chunks to 1-hour chunks depending on the size of the city.

Wilderness: If the map describes a kingdom, county, or other large region of the world, then points might be settlements, dungeons, or major landmarks, and the lines between them are roads and trails. Travel time between points of a region take a number of hours or whole days.

Wandering Encounters
NPCs occupy these locations. NPCs don't just sit around and wait for the player characters, they wander. When the player characters encounter the wandering NPCs, this is called a wandering encounter. In a point crawl, it can happen on a point or a line. Wandering encounters are important because they add unpredictability (even danger) which can make the location feel like a real, believable place.

Rates of wandering encounters are based on scale (dungeon, settlement, or wilderness). The GM may roll for wandering encounters every other turn in a dungeon. Daytime or nighttime may also affect the kinds and the frequency of encounters. In the wilderness, the GM may roll twice each turn, where one roll represents day and the other is night.

Rolls are made by the GM. There is a one in six (1d6) chance of an encounter. On a 1, an NPC (or NPC group) appears nearby. The NPC may appear at the point the PCs are moving to, or they may appear on an adjacent line and traveling towards that point. This creates variability in circumstances. One side may appear first or detect the other side in advanced, allowing one side a choice to avoid the encounter. Quietly assign each path one to two numbers on a 1d6. The point gets the remaining numbers. Then roll to determine where the wandering encounter appears.

GM Tips: Wandering encounters add challenge but that's not all. When done well, wandering encounters benefit immersion and verisimilitude. When done poorly, they slow down the game or make the game get stuck. You may handwave wandering encounters for the sake of pacing and immersion, not to go easy on the players.

Rare magic items have 1 tag. Very rare magic items have 2 tags. Cursed items have one cursed tag and one beneficial tag. Relics have 3 to 4 tags.


MAGIC ITEMS
+1 bonuses in Bright-Dark are massive; therefore, magic items in Bright-Dark rarely have numerical bonuses. Instead, magic items have tags that define abilities. The GM can add one tag to an item. Create your own magic items using these tags below or create your own tags. Magic items should change the story, not math. Keep them rare, personal, and meaningful.

Rare magic items have 1 tag. Very rare magic items have 2 tags. Cursed items have one cursed tag and one beneficial tag. Relics have 3 to 4 tags.

Utility Tags
Lights on CommandThis item lights up like a torch on command
Water WalkingThe wearer can walk and stop on the surface of water
FloatsThe wearer ignores hazardous terrain and moves Fast
Storm ConjuringThis item conjures a powerful wind once
IndestructibleThis item cannot break and does not wear
TelepathyCommunicate telepathically with one person
ShapeshiftingThe item shapeshifts to fit the wearer or suit the wielder's needs
AnimatedThe object animates on command and can be controlled remotely
TelekinesisLimited telekinesis within Near range; costs 1 Stamina to lift heavier-than-handheld objects

Combat Tags
Magic WeaponDamages enemies resistant to mundane harm
BaneDeals 1d6 bonus damage to a specific creature type
Flames on CommandIgnites like a torch and deals magical fire damage instead of mundane damage
Life ShieldIf reduced to 0 HP, wearer stays at 1 HP (1× per scene)
KeenCritical hits on a natural 16–18

Protection Tags
Elemental ProtectionProtected from fire and cold
Spirit WardProtects wearer against possession
Charm ProtectionProtects wearer against charm
RegenerationRegenerates +1 Health per day
Magic ShieldHalf damage from magic attacks
RepellingTemporarily repels a specific enemy type on command

Mystic Tags
ConjuringConjures a single, specific creature (genie, guardian spirit, a nearby plant or beast, etc.)
Curse of CompulsionItem cannot be removed; compels the wearer to...
Curse of WeaknessItem cannot be removed; sets Strength to -3
Of SeeingGrants visions; sometimes when wanted, usually when needed
SapientItem can reason and telepathically communicate
SentientItem can feel and empathically communicate
CompassPoints toward a specific object or category of objects


OPTIONAL MAGIC RULES
For optional magic rules such as signature spells, wild magic, and optional magic talents, please see the Magic Section.


SURVIVAL MECHANICS
Bright-Dark 3d6 Role-Playing Game intentionally avoids survival mechanics, but if survival mechanics suits your style, use the following rules:

Food & Water
Quantities of food and water are abstract. Any amount of food or water counts as enough for one day.

Dehydration
  • 1 day without water means you're dehydrated
  • Dehydration kills in 3 days
  • Dehydrated characters suffer:
    • -1 situational penalty
    • NPCs gain a +1 situational bonus against them

Starvation
  • 3 days without food means you're starving
  • Starvation kills is 7 days (one full week)
  • Starving characters suffer:
    • -1 situational penalty
    • NPCs gain a +1 situational bonus against them
These penalties exist within the faction. 

Shelter & Exposure
Shelter protects against environmental hazards such as heat, cold, wind, and rain.

Shelter may be:
  • A sleeping bag
  • A warm blanket
  • A tent
  • A building
  • Any fictionally appropriate cover

Cold
  • Mild cold impairs sleep and leads to exhaustion (within the fiction)
  • Freezing cold can kill in one night
  • Characters without adequate shelter suffer narrative consequences (shivering, numbness, slowed movement)

Heat
  • Extreme heat doubles water requirements
  • Extreme heat reduces dehydration time (death in 2 days)
  • Characters may suffer heat exhaustion, disorientation, or collapse in fiction

Illness & Infection
Illness may arise from:
  • Insect bite
  • Poisonous plants
  • Spoiled food
  • Contaminated water
  • Untreated wounds

Timeline
  • Incubation: 1 day or night
  • Onset: 1–3 days of illness (the duration depends on the illness)

Recovery
If the illness is severe (depending on the illness):
  • Roll Endurance to recover. The Difficulty TN depends on the illness.
  • On failure, repeat the illness duration
  • After each repeated duration, either:
    • Recover automatically, or
    • Roll Endurance again to repeat the duration

Medical Intervention
A trained expert:
  • Ends the illness duration
  • Allows automatic recovery to begin

This keeps illness narrative-driven while giving players meaningful decisions. If you use Survival Mechanics, consider adding this optional Talent:

Optional Talent: Healer
You are a trained Healer or Doctor. You can diagnose illnesses, identify natural remedies, and prepare simple medicines. When treating an illness, you may end its duration immediately, allowing recovery to begin without requiring an Endurance roll.


INVENTORY MANAGEMENT & ENCUMBRANCE
if you want inventory management, here's a simple system. With this system, characters are assumed to have a backpack or similar carrying container.

Carrying Capacity
Characters can carry a load of 10 + Strength items. At character Improvement, they can choose to improve their carrying capacity by +1 items up to a cap of 20 + Strength items. If characters are carrying their full load, they are encumbered. Encumbrance is condition within the fiction and penalties are situational. Exceeding this load can be done within reason, but the character moves at Slow speed (15 ft / turn).

Weight and Size. Items that are heavy or bulky can be carried within reason. Use your judgment and ask what a real person could believably carry. For example, two suits of heavy armor or ten 10 ft pole-arms sounds unreasonable.

Bulk Quantities. Multiple quantities of small light items are counted as one item. For simplicity, use multiples of 5. 5 Torches. 5 days rations (if used). Rope 50 ft = 1 item. An ammo container holds 20 pieces of ammunition. Coins or gems (if used) up to 500. Don't track individual tools if a tool kit can be tracked instead. Example: a sewing kit or doctor's bag.

Petty items. Items of insignificant size and weight like keys, flint and steel, a personal token like a signet ring, or a holy symbol, can be handwaved unless carried in bulk quantities.

Optional Talent: Strong Back. You can carry 15 + Strength items rather than 10 + Strength items.


SUPPLIES
This simple optional rule pairs with survival and inventory management.

Supplies are an abstraction of things like food, water, and first aid supplies to clean and dress wounds. GMs, consider expanding supplies to include other types of items such as rope (50 ft), pitons x10, a hammer, or a flask of lamp oil. Supplies as a game mechanic are a quantum item; they become a fixed, permanent item within the game or fiction only when the player declares what that supply represents upon using or spending it.

For inventory management, 10 supplies count as one item.
For survival, 1 supply = one day of food or one day of water. Characters need two supplies daily to meet their basic needs.

This approach eliminates weight tracking, simplifies shopping, rewards preparation without exhaustive gear lists, and allows some implementation of resource management.


WEALTH (Optional Rule)
This optional rule measures social and economic position rather than counting coins. Wealth is not intended as a reward loop. It exists to answer the question: Can I afford that?

Commoner Class. You can afford simple meals and lodging. New equipment may be difficult to obtain and often requires favors, promises, or negotiation.

Adventuring Class. You can afford all equipment assumed by the core rules and live modestly while pursuing your adventures.

Merchant Class. Either you have the backing of a merchant, or you own property, investments, or a successful business. Most equipment, travel, and ordinary services are easy to obtain.

Noble Class. Money is not an object. Your challenges are matters of reputation, duty, power, and relationships. The things you need cannot usually be purchased with gold. A bribe, for example, is an act that recontextualizes your character.

Player characters in Bright-Dark 3d6 RPG are assumed to be ordinary people. GMs, with this optional rule, the player characters' starting class should suit the campaign and the tone. Should you permit their starting character concept of a merchant or noble, they must have a situation in which they begin with none of the economic, political, or social benefits such as an ex-merchant or a former noble.


HEALTH ALTERNATIVE: INJURY SYSTEM
Instead of rolling for damage and tracking health, we instead track physical wounds or injuries. These are abstract and exist within the fiction as flavor, not numeric or mechanical.
  • Any hit is counted as one injury.
  • A critical hit causes a severe injury which is counted as two injuries for gameplay purposes.
  • At three injuries, a character is unconscious.
  • Characters recover from injuries at a rate of one injury every three days.
With this alternative system, characters take one injury if they fall 20 feet, two injuries at 30 feet, and 3 injuries at 40 feet. If they fall 50 feet or greater, they perish.


ALTERNATIVE COMBAT
Bright-Dark's built-in combat rules are intended for fast, simple combat that focuses on the narrative and deemphasizes tactics and strategy. If you prefer a more traditional TTRPG combat system, use this instead.

Surprise
Characters who are distracted, asleep, unconscious, or otherwise unaware of a hostile adversary or unable to react timely within the fiction are surprised.

Surprised characters lose their first turn.

Turn Order
The GM rolls 1d6 to determine which side acts first. 
  • 1-3: The NPCs act first. 
  • 4-6: The Players act first
Players take their turns clockwise around the table.

Turns
On player turns, players may: 
  • Make one action, and 
  • Move up to their normal movement as part of their action. 
Attacking ends your turn!

The player declares their action, the GM resolves the action, and then the next player takes their turn.

This alternative combat system is more familiar to TTRPGs and may be easier for them to learn and play.


STRUCTURED MAGIC
If Bright-Dark 3d6's freeform magic system is too unstructured for you, consider using this list of words that describe the shape or form of the spell. This describes who it can affect, and how. Consider that any ranged spells should require the caster to be able to see the space or the target that they are trying to hit with their spell (which is often called line of sight in games). Anything that affects an area (multiple characters or objects) is a major spell.

Touch  
Magic delivered through physical contact.
Examples: healing warmth, burning grip, conductive energy.

Bolt  
A narrow, focused projection of magical force.
Examples: a streak of fire, a lance of light, a crackling spark.

Blast, Cone, or Line
A sudden, explosive burst of magic. It affects an area with a diameter of one pencil.
Examples: a fireburst, a shockwave, a concussive flare, a cone-shaped breath

Aura  
A field of magic that surrounds the caster or a target with a diameter of a pencil.
Examples: a glow of protection, a haze of heat, a shimmering veil.

Mark  
Magic that leaves a lingering effect or symbol.
Examples: a sigil, a brand, a glowing rune.

Field
Magic that effects a specific area and persists for a short duration. Diameter: 1 pencil length.
Examples: a concealing fog, a hazardous outcrop of rocks or plant growth, an illusion, 

Remote
Magic that crosses space without affecting anything in between.
Examples: Telepathy, a charming gaze


LEVELS & EXPERIENCE POINTS
This is a simple experience point system that replaces the default milestone leveling. It keeps bookkeeping low but preserves concepts of levels and experience points for those who enjoy these aspects of gaming. 

Player characters ordinarily begin play at level 1, or else they begin play at the same level as the player character with the lowest level. The level cap is 10.

Characters need 10 experience points to level up at any level. Players must rest for a night in order to gain the benefits of their level.

At the end of the session, the GM awards 1-4 experience points (XP) to each player. XP is not split or divided. The XP award is based on the difficulty of the challenges rather than how much the player characters accomplish. A 2 XP session describes a session of ordinary difficulty. A 4 XP session describes the most difficult session.

The GM may award 1 bonus XP to players who made a significant or standout contribution to the party's efforts, or who took a significant risk. Players can earn only 1 bonus XP per session. This is not intended to turn the game competitive; rather, it's intended to encourage participation.

No XP are earned by absentee players because points of experience are earned for having experiences.


METACURRENCY - LIGHT DICE
Any time a player does or says something that exemplifies an act of kindness, courage, or hope, but does not require a 3d6 roll, the GM may award that player one Light Die. This rewards players for actions that would ordinarily earn a light bonus but do not have a roll.

One Light Die can be spent to:
  • Roll 4d6 and drop the lowest for any of their own 3d6 rolls
  • Add 1d6 to any of their own damage rolls (or healing rolls if using magic) 
  • Roll 1d6 and reduce damage they receive from a single attack by that amount

Wednesday, September 16, 2026

Bright‑Dark 3d6 — Version 0.9 Now Available



Bright‑Dark 3d6 Role-Playing Game Version 0.9 Now Available at

I have created an itch.io page for Bright-Dark 3d6 Role-Playing Game. I intend to take this project to a solid version 1.0 in time. No rush. Just steady refinement. The goal is to create a self-contained, one and done document that contains all you need to play.

Before I get there, I will need feedback. What are the strengths? What could use improving? I am hoping to gather views, commentary, and impressions as people read and try the game.

Comments welcome. Shares welcome. More content to come.

You can also read the full game here on my blog:
Bright-Dark 3d6 Role-Playing Game

Download: Character Sheet

Sunday, March 29, 2026

Managing Expectations in TTRPGs - Discussing What We Do and Don't Like

When it comes to TTRPGs like D&D and Pathfinder (pronounced pat-h-fin-der), I think the trickiest part is managing expectations. That is to say that I have had a lot of personal experience with trying to run one kind of game, and players trying to play another kind of game, or vice versa if I'm a player. For me, it's very unsatisfying to tell players, "I'm running a game for heroic characters", and someone still brings a joke character, and someone else still brings a character of neutral alignment and needs some extra motivation to do anything. Ugh.

This article is my attempt to work out a way to manage these expectations. The first thing is to identify the motives, experiences, interests and influences of the participants. Some people's only exposure to fantasy might be Adventure Time. You might think I'm making that up, but I'm not! I have played with that guy. He didn't know any of the classic fantasy conventions and he played like it.

We're going to start with some useful vocabulary. Ask and discuss these questions:
  • Influences or Interests: What movies, books, comics, video games, tv, etc. have you seen? that you like? What do you like about them?
  • Disinterests: What do you dislike about TTRPGs, genres, literary conventions, etc. Some people are open to anything, some people aren't! For people with discerning tastes, this is as important.
  • Experiences: Previous experiences with TTRPG(s). What did you like about them, what did you not like? Players may have learned some things that you would like them to unlearn.
  • Motives: Why are you interested in TTRPGs? What about this hobby is fun for you? What makes you want to play a TTRPG?

My Interests: My favorite work of Fantasy might just be Kentaro Miura's Berserk. Let's discuss why. The art is badass. The dark themes are interesting. The scenarios are interesting. There's a sort of cosmic horror to it. Guts is just this regular guy who manages to become above average by sheer effort and a will to survive. He has an extraordinary tenacity for survival in the face of overwhelming odds. His opponents are often otherworldly and nightmarish in power and scale but they have such simple motives like eating people or avoiding boredom. He even earns their respect with his will and fortitude. What else? It's otherwise a low-magic, earth-like setting. The horror elements almost replace the fantastic elements, and I think that's really cool!

I also like Vampire Hunter D for some similar reasons, and because I think it's stylish as hell. In this setting, Vampires became the rulers of the earth. To the extent that the word noble became synonymous with vampire and few people use the word vampire. Humans are cattle. That's pretty dark. The titular character is D, and he's a Dhampir. That means he is a half human half vampire. Because of this, he's rejected by both humans and vampires. He's also secretly the most badass character in the setting. The question is what does he want and why? It seems to me that the author intends to leave these things up to interpretation or inference, but we are to come away believing that this is not a character with ordinary motivations.

Tim Burton's Sleepy Hallow was pretty fucking stylish too. In this movie, everyone's dressed in a period era outfit, there's only one monster and he's an absolute badass, no one understands the monster or magic, and the fantastic elements are not casually accepted by anyone. They're all as wild as if you went out for a walk and met an extra-terrestrial.

Generally, low fantasy settings or earth-like settings where the supernatural or extraordinary are rare and maybe even intrusive upon the ordinary world are interesting. Monsters are monsters! Magic is dangerous or even forbidden. The elements of the fantasy that make fantasy unique are kept low so that they when they are used, they have a greater effect, like a guy who never says curse words finally dropping an f-bomb. I also like the low fantasy, dark fantasy Campaign Diaries of Professor DM on the Dungeon Craft YouTube channel!

Disney's Pirates of the Caribbean is cool for similar reasons. The fantastic elements are presented as curses, and they present the supernatural as dangerous and mysterious. If you had to assign all the characters in that movie a D&D class, they would either be fighters or thieves (rogues). 

My Disinterests: You might think I don't actually like fantasy, and there might be something to that, but I don't like pure horror and I'm not into the horror TTRPGs because in those you play as a survivor or a victim. I do want to be a hero. Fantasy can be pretty @#$%^ nerdy. The way nerds use wizards, vampires, demons, and lycanthropes can be really cringy because they make it mundane and ordinary. Monsters aren't monsters anymore, they're just like cat people or something. And then there's people who think it's racist to kill monsters and take their stuff, and those people are just detrimental to the hobby. I don't like elves, dwarves, hobbits, and some of the other fantastic races that have become standard like Tieflings, half-orcs, and dragonborn (dragon people). These things make me feel like I'm watching the Muppets. I don't like that magic is common and ordinary, like a skill or an art that people can just pick up and learn. What's so special about magic if everyone can do it?

My Experiences: I have mostly played 5e D&D. It's pretty lame. There's furries. There's scalies. Goblins, bugbears, and other monsters are humanoids or goblinoids, and so they're treated like an exotic people. I don't like that. Demons from the Christian hell are not people. Even goblins should be monstrous. D&D makes me feel like I'm Eddie Valiant in Who Framed Roger Rabit. Tonally, it's lame. Players play these goofy characters, or they make characters who are kind of goofy conceptually but are intended to be played serious. It makes it difficult for me to care. I don't care about non-humans, and I don't care to humanize the non-humans. I'm hoping for something more serious, but this can't help but feel cartoonish. Besides that, the player characters get pretty powerful, and after a while they play like they know they are. Powerful player characters are antithetical to horror. I have played mostly in Faerun and Eberron, and slightly in Draconlance, Spelljammer, the Underdark, and Greyhawk; but I think 5e modernized it all made it all lame. It's casual and accessible and safe. Even the modern Ravenloft setting is kind of watered down and plebian. I also hate chaotic and evil player characters! They're dicks and they spoil someone's fun. I want PCs who can play as a damn team. And I don't want to be a villainous character, and I don't want to be a character who would particularly tolerate villainous companions or allies. But when you play D&D, this game permits evil and chaotic player characters, and so do most GMs, so I have to put up with it.

Motives: I have lost interest in tv, movies, comics, anime, and books because I think it used to be good, now it's not; but I still want to indulge in some narrative entertainment. I want an outlet for creativity, I want to socialize, and I want to play a game!

I think this was a particularly interesting exercise and I recommend you all do the same.

Here's what I learned about myself: I am not down for any game.

I want an earth-like or low fantasy, human-centric setting where magic and monsters are rare and dangerous. The line between fantasy and horror is blurred. Monsters are not people, they are monsters, and they are opposed to humanity. Magic-users are rare, maybe even feared and hated. Stakes are low, not epic. Characters are generally relatable; scenarios are generally plausible; environments are generally realistic. Your character is an ordinary or above average person. You are not great, but you can earn greatness. You have a chance to become a hero, and I want you to aspire to be, but if you become a villain, I take your PC and make them an NPC in my setting, and they become the property of the me, the GM. Don't do anything you wouldn't do in real life. Play your character like you care what happens to them. This is low, dark fantasy.

This post pairs well with my five‑rule guide for managing expectations, which turns these ideas into practical tools you can use in Session Zero and character creation.

If you want a deeper foundation for the ideas in this post, my TTRPG Concepts glossary explains the vocabulary behind tone, realism, stakes, immersion, and playstyle.

Wednesday, August 27, 2025

Mid Fantasy

I would like to coin some new words. Hyper is a prefix meaning over, beyond, above. Hypo is a prefix meaning below, under, or slight. They describe more / less than normal or average.

Hyperfantasy means a style of fantasy where the fantastic is present is a high amount, or a high abundance. It is not the same as high fantasy. High fantasy describes a full fantastic, fictional world or setting. Hyperfantastic describes a style of story or setting where there would appear to be more fantastic stuff than real stuff. The frequency of the fantastic is so common that the fantastic is ordinary and mundane. It might not even be exotic anymore. Consider the show Aventure Time.

Hypofantasy is the opposite. It describes a style of fantasy where the fantastic is very rare to the point that it might not be recognized as a fantasy at a glance. There might be one fantastic object or character in the whole story that appears mostly grounded, like the first three Indiana Jones films. It might seem redundant when you consider low fantasy can describe the same thing, but the distinction is that low fantasy describes the setting, and hypofantasy describes the quantity of fantastic elements. You could have a high fantasy setting where the fantastic seems to have been lost.

What's the point? Mostly, I want these concepts in the vernacular because when I say fantasy, no one knows what I kind of fantasy mean. They assume hyperfantasy more than not.

You know what, sod it. I think mid fantasy will suit me. I'm copy/pasting the definition from AI below:

Mid-fantasy, or middle fantasy, is an informal genre term describing settings that fall between high fantasy and low fantasy, often featuring a secondary world with fantastical elements that are more grounded and less pervasive than in high fantasy, and magic that is uncommon but present, along with common elements like political intrigue, realistic or semi-realistic characters, and less epic stakes.

👍